الوضع التجريبي Beta mode

An Analytical Review of the Accuracy of Classifying Tropical System “Shakti”: A comparison between the National Multi-Hazard Early Warning Centre Classification and the Regional and International Centres

During early October 2025, meteorological centres monitored Tropical System “Shakti” over the Arabian Sea as it evolved through several stages of development and weakening. Although the system remained over the sea, it indirectly affected parts of the Sultanate of Oman through cloud advection, scattered rainfall, and sea level rise along some coastal areas.

Development Stages of Tropical System

The Tropical System “Shakti” developed from a tropical disturbance over the northeastern Arabian Sea along the Indian Coast on 28 September. It intensified into a tropical depression on 2 October, then into a deep depression on 3 October, before rapidly developing into a tropical storm later that day and reaching Category 1 tropical cyclone on 4 October. After reaching its peak intensity, the system began to gradually weaken. It downgraded to a tropical storm on 5 October, then a deep depression on 6 October, and subsequently to a tropical depression on 7 October.

Track of the Tropical System

The tropical system was moving southwestward toward the southeastern coasts of Oman before veering southeastward over the Arabian Sea from 6 October. It exhibited limited oscillation in its movement due to its gradual weakening. This weakening resulted from its interaction with upper-air currents and wind shear in the mid-upper troposphere (200-500 hPa). As a consequence, the system drifted southward and then southwestward over the Central Arabian Sea, while continuing to weaken as a low-pressure system before its dissipation.

Figure: The track of Tropical System “Shakti” according to different Meteorological Centres.

Impacts of the Tropical System

The impacts of Tropical System “Shakti” were indirect and included cloud advection over the coastal areas of Al Sharqiyah South, Al Wusta, and Dhofar governorates, leading to scattered rain.

The system was also accompanied by sea level rise and inundation of seawater into low-lying coastal areas and inlets, coinciding with high tides

Comparison of Classification among Meteorological Centres

A discrepancy was observed in the classification of the tropical system “Shakti” among Oman Meteorology, the India Regional Specialised Meteorological Centre (RSMC), and the Joint Typhoon Warning Centre (JTWC), as well as satellite-based Dvorak intensity estimates. However, a high level of consistency was observed between Oman Meteorology and the India RSMC across most classification stages. On the other hand, a clear difference was noted with JTWC, which was quicker to upgrade the system to a tropical cyclone than other centres.

The Dvorak estimates, and JTWC agreed in classifying the system as a tropical storm during the early stages, whereas Oman Meteorology and the India RSMC maintained a deep depression classification during that period.

However, agreement was observed between Oman Meteorology and the Dvorak estimates when the system was classified as a Category one Tropical cyclone. During the weakening stages, all centres reported a decrease in the system’s intensity with some differences in the estimated wind speeds.

This variation in the classification of the tropical system “Shakti” across centres can be attributed to differences in surface wind speed estimation methodologies and the classification criteria adopted by each centre.

DateUTCOman MeterologyIndia RSMCJTWCDvorak estimates
30/911:00 AMTropical Depression (20-27 knots)Tropical Depression (15-20 knots)Tropical Depression (25 knots)T1.0 – Tropical Depression (25 knots)
2/1011:15 AMTropical Depression (20-27 knots)Tropical Depression (25 knots)Deep Tropical Depression (30 knots)T2.5 – Tropical Depression (30 knots)
3/104:30 AMDeep Tropical DepressionDeep Tropical Depression (30 knots)Tropical Storm (35 knots)T3.0 – Tropical Storm (45 knots)
3/1010:50 AMTropical StormTropical Storm (35-40 knots)Tropical Storm (40-45 knots)T3.0 – Tropical Storm (45 knots)
4/1011:00 AMTropical Storm (45-55 knots)Severe Tropical Storm (55 knots)Tropical Cyclone (1) (55-65 knots)T3.0 – Tropical Storm (55 knots)
4/109:00 PMTropical Cyclone (1) (64-70 knots)Severe Tropical Storm (55-60 knots)Tropical Cyclone (1) (70-75 knots)T4.0 – Tropical Cyclone (1) (55-77 knots)
5/1011:00 AMTropical Storm (40-55 knots)Severe Tropical Storm (55-60 knots)Tropical Cyclone (1) (60-64 knots)T4.0 – Tropical Cyclone (1) (77 knots)
6/1006:45 AMDeep Tropical Depression (28-33 knots)Tropical Storm (35-45 knots)Tropical Storm (40 knots)T3.0 – Tropical Storm (35-45 knots)
6/1011:00 AMDeep Tropical Depression (28-33 knots)Tropical Storm (35-45 knots)Tropical Storm (35-40 knots)T2.5 – Tropical Storm (35 knots)
7/1006:45 AMTropical Depression (17-27 knots)Tropical Depression (20 knots)
Table: Comparison of the Classification and Intensity Estimates of Tropical System “Shakti” among Meteorological Centres.

Conclusion

Tropical System “Shakti” was characterized by gradual development and weakening over the Arabian Sea, with indirect impacts on the Sultanate of Oman. Differences were observed in the classification, and intensity estimates among meteorological centres due to variations in analysis methods and wind estimation techniques. Despite these differences, the system was monitored closely throughout its lifecycle, and overall agreement was observed regarding its general track and weakening trend.